In terms of choosing an eyeliner shade, it depends on how soft or intense you want to go. If you want a softer effect, choose a cool-toned brown or taupe. “I like grayish browns, because the finish looks like a shadow,” says Soleimani, who likes to create a faint wing with a small liner brush for a “soft and muted” flick effect. To achieve maximum definition, go for a dark brown or black in an eye pencil or liquid liner. “At this time I love it for Zoom, because it lends definition to the Cat-I-Do-What-I-Want-Madafakas-Vintage-shirt eyes so they look more impactful,” she adds. What’s more: If you want to add to the drama, or transition your liner from day to night, tightlining is a great way to start a cat-eye or kitten flick.